Jump directly to content

Hybrid threats only become apparent when you put the pieces together

A cyberattack here, a rumor on social media there, and a drone flying over a port. Taken individually, these events may seem isolated. Together, they could be part of a larger attack. To effectively counter hybrid threats, organizations must therefore practice identifying connections, sharing information, and taking action when the situation is unclear.

When Individual Events Form a Pattern
Sara Lidbaum is a project manager and expert on hybrid threats at the Center for Security Design and Innovation at RISE. Together with the Swedish National Defense College and colleagues at RISE, she has developed “Confronting Hybrid Threats,” a game-based tool for education, training, and exercises.

A question she often hears from municipalities, government agencies, and companies is what a hybrid threat actually is.

“It’s when an actor—often a foreign state—combines several different means to weaken us without it escalating into open conflict.” This can include cyberattacks, disinformation, economic pressure, sabotage, or threats against individuals. What makes it ‘hybrid’ is that these methods work in concert,” says Sara Lidbaum.

It is precisely this combination that makes the threats difficult to detect. One incident might end up with the IT department, another with the communications team, and a third with an entirely different part of the organization.

“Each incident ends up with its own recipient. The IT department handles the breach, the communications team handles the rumor, and the police handle the vandalism. No one sees the whole picture. That’s exactly what the attacker is counting on,” says Sara Lidbaum.

“No one sees the whole picture. That's exactly what the attacker is counting on.”

Sara Lidbaum, project manager and expert on hybrid threats

Would you realize that these things are connected?

The ability to counter hybrid threats is therefore not just about being familiar with different types of threats. The organization also needs to be able to see connections between events and share information so that someone can grasp the big picture.

Sara Lidbaum describes a scenario in which a phishing email sent to a subcontractor sets off a chain of events. The attacker moves on to a municipal energy company, and the district heating system goes down. At the same time, the municipality’s website becomes overloaded, and information questioning the municipality’s handling of the situation spreads on social media.

If these events are treated in isolation, they easily become an IT incident here and a communications issue there. The challenge is recognizing that they may be connected.

 

“It’s about having procedures in place for reporting and sharing observations, so that someone has a chance to see the big picture,” says Sara Lidbaum.

It’s Possible to Train for the Difficult Scenarios

How do you train for a situation where information is incomplete and it may not even be clear that the organization is under attack?

RISE addresses hybrid threats through education, training, and exercises. Together with the Swedish National Defense University’s Center for Total Defense and Societal Security (CTSS), RISE has developed materials that make it possible to practice dealing with precisely these situations.

A central component is “Facing Hybrid Threats,” a game-based tool where participants follow a scenario that unfolds step by step. The group discusses what is happening, identifies connections between different events, and decides how the organization should respond.

“The game-based format makes an abstract topic concrete. People from different parts of the organization sit around the same table and discover that they each hold different pieces of the puzzle,” says Sara Lidbaum.

There is no single correct answer. Instead, the point is the discussion and the opportunity to practice making decisions when the information is incomplete.

From an initial introduction to building your own capabilities

Organizations have different needs and are at different levels. That’s why there are different ways to get started.

For those who need a common foundation, there is the Basic Training in Hybrid Threats, where lectures are interspersed with practical exercises and group reflection. The training provides participants with an introduction to what hybrid threats are and the opportunity to immediately test their knowledge in an exercise.

The game-based tool “Addressing Hybrid Threats” can also be used independently within an organization. It requires neither technical expertise nor prior knowledge and enables groups to train together.

For organizations that want to be able to continue the work on their own, there is the “Training of Trainers: Hybrid Threats” program. Over the course of a full day, participants gain knowledge and practical training in leading education, training, and exercises using the tool. The training also includes mentor support for ongoing work.

“It’s the emergency preparedness coordinator, the security manager, or the trainer who knows their organization best. When they can lead the exercises themselves, they can tie them to their own daily routines. That way, the skills become something that lasts, rather than something that disappears when we go home,” says Sara Lidbaum.

The method is also used internationally

Work on hybrid threats is also taking place internationally. By 2027, the game-based tool will be available in English, Norwegian, Romanian, and Ukrainian. Education, training, and exercises using the game-based tool are taking place in several countries as well as in collaboration with NATO. This demonstrates how a method for collaborative learning and scenario-based training can be used in various national contexts to develop the capability to counter hybrid threats.
 

Do you want to strengthen your ability to detect and respond to hybrid threats?

This capability must be kept alive. A one-time training session is not the end goal. Threats evolve, personnel change, and this capability must be maintained. Through ongoing education, training, and drills, your organization can continue to develop its ability to recognize patterns and take action when the situation is unclear.

RISE’s offerings range from basic knowledge to tools and training for those who will lead exercises themselves. Contact us for more information.

Sara Lidbaum

Projektledare
+46 10 228 40 18 Read more about Sara

Contact Sara

CAPTCHA

* Mandatory 

By submitting the form, RISE will process your personal data.